Having reactivated my Facebook membership last month I’m sorry to say that Facebook is back on my list of daily distractions. It’s fun, although the actual benefits to my life (let alone my productivity) are marginal at best. Anyway, today I’ve spent a few minutes playing around with the new design and here are my thoughts…
What I like:
- When you’re viewing other people’s Profile, the new Profile page is great. Wall content (the stuff that changes) is now up the top of the page. Inputing content to other people’s Wall is now a lot easier too as form is at the very top.
- Adding filters to the Wall is useful (I think the Facebook team use Digg!)
- Wider page width works better on bigger monitors and I’m glad the design remains fixed width.
- Search box is now in the header where you expect it.
- Bigger photos make sense.
- When viewing your own Profile, you can finally edit your Profile information from this page. Previously you had to navigate your way to “Account” to do this which was clumsy.
What I don’t like:
- Now that Wall content seems to include what was previously “Mini Feeds”, when the fancy new filter is set to “All posts” (as it is by default) the design feels difficult to read. Previously Wall items were separated by a small version of people’s Profile photos and a horizontal line which made scanning for new posts easy. Now that it includes a mix of photos, icons and different background colours…it’s hard for your eye to separate where one post ends and the next post begins.
- The little yellow help boxes everywhere are annoying and need a “close” option. Hopefully this will come sooner rather than later.
- The huge “what are you doing now” form at the top of your own Profile feels OTT to me. Perhaps it’s a shot at Twitter?
- On the same note…I notice a lot of the forms are now expanded by default where as previously you had to click to view them. I like the old way better.
- I miss the drop down box on the “Friends” button where you could jump straight to “status updated” “recently updated” “recently added”
Overall though, I think it’s pretty good and it’s clear to me that Facebook has put a lot of thought into giving more weighting to the elements of the page people are using most often. I also like the fact that Facebook hasn’t done a MySpace and has so far resisted the temptation to let people use HTML and other methods of visual customisation on their Profiles.
When working on my own sites I’ve found that it’s often not until after the design has left Photoshop and I’ve *used* the site extensively that I get a feel for what works and what doesn’t. We seldom get it right first time (or the second or third or fourth for that matter!) and evolution is key. It’s fun to see much bigger sites like Facebook follow a similar process.
If you use Facebook I’d love to hear your thoughts. So leave a comment!

Latest Comments